WHAT IF: Mystery Tales Vol. 5 Map by Chris Leazer: reprints Mystery Tales #45-54 (260 pages) September/56: Mystery Tales #45 (25? pages + cover) Cover Credits: Sol Brodsky (pencils); Carl Burgos? (inks) "The Man In Black!" (4? pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "The Secret Of the Old House!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "unknown" (3 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) text story "unknown" (2 pages) Credits: Unknown (script) "unknown" (4? pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Robert Q. Sale (pencils); Robert Q. Sale (inks) "unknown" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "He Stayed Down Too Long!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) October/56: Mystery Tales #46 (25 pages + cover) Cover Credits: Bill Everett (pencils); Bill Everett (inks) "Forbidden!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); John Forte (pencils); John Forte (inks) "Crisis!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Don Heck (pencils); Don Heck (inks) "Where Is Lola Drake?" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "The Fake" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Al Williamson (pencils); Al Williamson (inks) text story "The Traveller" (2 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Reed Crandall (pencils); Reed Crandall (inks) "The Strange Man" (3 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Sol Brodsky (pencils); Sol Brodsky (inks) "The Empty Room" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Robert Q. Sale (pencils); Robert Q. Sale (inks) November/56: Mystery Tales #47 (25 pages + cover) Cover Credits: Carl Burgos (pencils); Carl Burgos (inks) "The Man With No Face!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Robert Q. Sale (pencils); Robert Q. Sale (inks) "At the Stroke of Midnight!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Reed Crandall (pencils); Reed Crandall (inks) text story "The King of the Lions" (2 pages) Credits: Unknown (script) "The Only Woman!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "A Knock At the Door!" (3 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Bob Powell (pencils); Bob Powell (inks) "Something Strange About Smithtown!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Joe Certa (pencils); Joe Certa (inks) "When They Wake Up!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Steve Ditko (pencils); Steve Ditko (inks) December/56: Mystery Tales #48 (25 pages + cover) Cover Credits: Bill Everett (pencils); Bill Everett (inks) "The Man Who Was Erased!" (4? pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "unknown" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) text story "unknown" (2 pages) Credits: Unknown (script) "unknown" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "unknown" (3 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "unknown" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "unknown" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) January/57: Mystery Tales #49 (25 pages + cover) Cover Credits: Bill Everett (pencils); Bill Everett (inks) "By the Light of the Moon!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Bernie Krigstein (pencils); Bernie Krigstein (inks) "unknown" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "Time Without End" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Robert Q. Sale (pencils); Robert Q. Sale (inks) text story "unknown" (2 pages) Credits: Unknown (script) "unknown" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "Midnight On the Moors" (3 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Pete Morisi (pencils); Pete Morisi (inks) "The Ice Man!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Bernard Baily (pencils); Bernard Baily (inks) February/57: Mystery Tales #50 (25 pages + cover) Cover Credits: Bill Everett (pencils); Bill Everett (inks) "The Pyramid's Secret!" (4? pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "unknown" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "The Little Black Box" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Robert Q. Sale (pencils); Robert Q. Sale (inks) text story "unknown" (2 pages) Credits: Unknown (script) "unknown" (4? pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Angelo Torres (pencils); Angelo Torres (inks) "unknown" (3 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "unknown" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) March/57: Mystery Tales #51 (25 pages + cover) Cover Credits: Bill Everett (pencils); Unknown (inks) "Inside the Mummy Case" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Joe Orlando (pencils); Joe Orlando (inks) "The Lizard" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Al Williamson (pencils); Al Williamson (inks) "What World Is This?" (3 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Ross Andru (pencils); Mike Esposito (inks) "The Strange Seeds!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Ed Winiarski (pencils); Ed Winiarski (inks) text story "All In the Mind" (2 pages) Credits: Unknown (script) "I'll Get You Later" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Dave Berg (pencils); Dave Berg (inks) "Four Empty Chairs!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Marvin Stein (pencils); Marvin Stein (inks) April/57: Mystery Tales #52 (25 pages + cover) Cover Credits: John Severin (pencils); John Severin (inks) "Mystery of the Silent Fog!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Bernard Baily (pencils); Bernard Baily (inks) "The Fish Men!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) text story "The Broken Statue" (2 pages) Credits: Unknown (script) "The Betrayer" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Dick Ayers (pencils); Dick Ayers (inks) "The Too-Perfect Crime!" (3 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Pete Morisi (pencils); Pete Morisi (inks) "The City That Died!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "Midnight On the Moor!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) May/57: Mystery Tales #53 (25 pages + cover) Cover Credits: Bill Everett (pencils); Carl Burgos (inks) "The People That Couldn't Move" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Dick Giordano (pencils); Dick Giordano (inks) "That's What You Think!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Frank Bolle (pencils); Frank Bolle (inks) "I Died Too Soon" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Marvin Stein (pencils); Marvin Stein (inks) "The Hired Hand" (3 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Manny Stallman (pencils); Manny Stallman (inks) text story "The Rainmaker" (2 pages) Credits: Unknown (script) "He Lived Again" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Ed Winiarski (pencils); Ed Winiarski (inks) "What Happened In Room 14?" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); John Forte (pencils); John Forte (inks) August/57: Mystery Tales #54 (25 pages + cover) Cover Credits: Fred Kida? (pencils); Fred Kida? (inks) "The Last Lap" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Reed Crandall (pencils); Reed Crandall (inks) "Prisoners of the Valley of Fear!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Jay Scott Pike (pencils); Jay Scott Pike (inks) "Death of a Gambling Man!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "Can of Soup" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Robert Q. Sale (pencils); Robert Q. Sale (inks) text story "Lost & Found" (2 pages) Credits: Unknown (script) "Nobody!" (4 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks) "The Labyrinth!" (3 pages) Credits: Unknown (script); Sid Check (pencils); Sid Check (inks) Mockup image by: David Juell

Website design by Doug Roberts and John Thomas. All images on this site are copyright of Marvel Comics. This site is for reference purposes and promotion of the Masterworks line of books as well as Marvel Comics and their properties.