> What If? Golden Age Maps


WHAT IF: All-Winners Comics Vol. 4

Map by Steve Rogers: reprints All-Winners Comics #14-19, 21 and [second series] #1 (323 pages)

*Note: Overstreet and Howard Keltner's index list no Human Torch story in #16, but the GCD Does. In addition, both Keltner and the GCD list an extended Captain America story in that issue, but neither agrees with the other on the size, and neither size fits the overall page count. The Captain America story will be treated as 12 pages which fits with the page count of the book, and others like it that Marvel published around the same time. How the extra Human Torch story fits in, I don't know.

Winter/44-45: All-Winners Comics #14 (32 pages + cover) 
Cover Credits: Alex Schomburg (penciler); Alex Schomburg (inker)

  • Sub-Mariner

    • "Twenty Million Missing" (12 pages)
    Credits: Unkown (writer); Allen Simon (penciler); Allen Simon (inker)
     
  • Captain America

    • "Monstro, the Mad Jap" (12 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Vince Alascia (penciler); Vince Alascia (inker)
     
  • Text Story

    • "Hill-Billy Tactics" (2 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer)
     
  • The Whizzer

    • "Kidnapper's Folly" (6 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Al Bellman (penciler); Al Fagaly (inker)
Spring/45: All-Winners Comics #15 (30 pages + cover) 
Cover Credits: Alex Schomburg (penciler); Alex Schomburg (inker)
  • Sub-Mariner

    • "The Man Who Killed Himself" (12 pages)
    Credits: Unkown (writer); Carl Pfeufer (penciler); Carl Pfeufer (inker)
     
  • Captain America

    • "The Masked Trio of Death" (8 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Vince Alascia (penciler); Mike Sekowsky (inker)
     
  • Text Story

    • "A Strange Story" (2 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer)
     
  • The Whizzer

    • "Lightning Strikes Twice" (7 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Louis Ferstadt (penciler); Louis Ferstadt (inker)
     
  • Let's Play Detective

    • "Juke Box Murder Case" (1 page)
    Credits: Unkown (writer); Al Bellman (penciler); Al Bellman (inker)
Summer/45: All-Winners Comics #16 (32 pages + cover)
Cover Credits: Alex Schomburg (penciler); Alex Schomburg (inker)
  • Sub-Mariner

    • "The Fabulous Racket" (12 pages)
    Credits: Unkown (writer); Allen Simon (penciler); Allen Simon (inker)
     
  • Captain America

    • "The Mystery of the Floating City" (12 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Vince Alascia (penciler); Mike Sekowsky (inker)
     
  • Text Story

    • "A Prince of a Guy" (2 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer)
     
  • The Whizzer

    • "Meteor III" (6 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Louis Ferstadt (penciler); Louis Ferstadt (inker)
Winter/45-46: All-Winners Comics #17 (45 pages + cover)
Cover Credits: Alex Schomburg (penciler); Alex Schomburg (inker)
  • Sub-Mariner

    • "The Black Phantom" (12 pages)
    Credits: Unkown (writer); Allen Simon (penciler); Allen Simon (inker)
     
  • Captain America

    • "The Curse of the Bayou Witch and Wizard" (11 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Al Avison (penciler); Vince Alascia (inker)
     
  • Text Story

    • "The Idol of Nokoa" (2 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer)
     
  • Human Torch

    • "The Voodoo Doll Murders" (12 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Al Gabriele (penciler); Al Gabriele (inker)
     
  • The Whizzer

    • "The Bank Jobs" (8 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Louis Ferstadt (penciler); Louis Ferstadt (inker)
Summer/46: All-Winners Comics #18 (44 pages + cover)
Cover Credits: Alex Schomburg (penciler); Alex Schomburg (inker)
  • Sub-Mariner

    • "The Case of the Baffling Neptune" (12 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Allen Simon (penciler); Allen Simon (inker)
     
  • Captain America

    • "The Silk Stocking Strangler" (12 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Vince Alascia (penciler); Harry Sahle? (inker)
     
  • Text Story

    • "Time Out For Crime" (2 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer)
     
  • Human Torch

    • "The Eye Has It" (12 pages)
    Credits: Unkown (writer); Allen Simon (penciler); Al Bellman (inker)
     
  • The Whizzer

    • "Unknown" (6 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Unknown (penciler); Unknown (inker)
Fall/46: All-Winners Comics #19 (45 pages + cover)
Cover Credits: Al Avison? (penciler); Al Gabriele? (inker)
  • The All-Winners Squad

    • "The Crime of the Ages (Ch. 1)" (5 pages)
    Credits: Bill Finger (writer); Syd Shores (penciler); Al Avison (inker)
     
  • Captain America

    • "The Age of Bronze (Ch. 2)" (8 pages)
    Credits: Bill Finger (writer); Vince Alascia (penciler); Bob Powell (inker)
     
  • The Whizzer

    • "The Iron Age (Ch. 3)" (6 pages)
    Credits: Bill Finger (writer); Al Avison (penciler); Al Gabriele (inker)
     
  • Human Torch

    • "The Steel Age (Ch. 4)" (8 pages)
    Credits: Bill Finger (writer); Al Avison (penciler); Don Rico (inker)
     
  • Text Story

    • "Pearls of Wisdom" (2 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer)
     
  • Miss America

    • "The Stone Age (Ch. 5)" (5 pages)
    Credits: Bill Finger (writer); Syd Shores (penciler); Vince Alascia (inker)
     
  • Sub-Mariner

    • "The Ice Age (Ch. 6)" (7 pages)
    Credits: Bill Finger (writer); Bob Powell (penciler); Al Avison (inker)
     
  • The All-Winners Squad

    • "Conclusion (Ch. 7)" (4 pages)
    Credits: Bill Finger (writer); Al Avison (penciler); Al Bellman (inker)
Winter/46-47: All-Winners Comics #21 (45 pages + cover)
Cover Credits: Al Avison (penciler); Charles Nicholas (inker)
  • The All-Winners Squad

    • "Menace From the Future World (Ch. 1)" (4 pages)
    Credits: Otto Binder (writer); Al Avison (penciler); Charles Nicholas (inker)
     
  • Captain America

    • "The Green Plague (Ch. 2)" (8 pages)
    Credits: Otto Binder (writer); Vince Alascia (penciler); Syd Shores (inker)
     
  • The Whizzer

    • "Murder In Slow Motion (Ch. 3)" (6 pages)
    Credits: Otto Binder (writer); Vince Alascia (penciler); George Klein? (inker)
     
  • Sub-Mariner

    • "Wave of Destruction (Ch. 4)" (8 pages)
    Credits: Otto Binder (writer); Al Avison (penciler); Vince Alascia (inker)
     
  • Text Story

    • "Holiday For Murder" (2 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer)
     
  • Miss America

    • "The Living Dead (Ch. 5)" (5 pages)
    Credits: Otto Binder (writer); Charles Nicholas (penciler); Syd Shores (inker)
     
  • Human Torch

    • "Flames of Fury (Ch. 6)" (8 pages)
    Credits: Otto Binder (writer); Syd Shores (penciler); Al Gabriele (inker)
     
  • The All-Winners Squad

    • "War Between the Worlds (Ch. 7)" (4 pages)
    Credits: Otto Binder (writer); Vince Alascia (penciler); Al Avison (inker)
8/48: All-Winners Comics #1 (Second Series) (42 pages + cover)
Cover Credits: Alex Schomburg (penciler); Alex Schomburg (inker)
  • Human Torch

    • "The Gay Blade of Terror" (10 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Carl Burgos? (penciler); Al Gabriele (inker)
     
  • Sub-Mariner

    • "Murder At Marlin Mansion" (12 pages)
    Credits: Unkown (writer); Bob Powell (penciler); Al Gabriele (inker)
     
  • Let's Play Detective

    • "Unknown" (1 page)
    Credits: Unkown (writer); Al Bellman (penciler); Al Bellman (inker)
     
  • Captain America

    • "Double Identity" (10 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Syd Shores (penciler); Syd Shores(inker)
     
  • Text Story

    • "Unknown" (2 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer)
     
  • The Blonde Phantom

    • "Personal Appearance For Murder" (7 pages)
    Credits: Unknown (writer); Al Bellman (penciler); Al Bellman (inker)

Mockup image by: David Spofforth
       
     

All cover images are courtesy of the
Silver Age Marvel Comics Cover Gallery.

     

Website design by Doug Roberts and John Thomas. All images on this site are copyright of Marvel Comics. This site is for reference purposes and promotion of the Masterworks line of books as well as Marvel Comics and their properties.